Ahhh, Christmas.

The most wonderful time of the year, right?

Warm fires, twinkling lights, and the sweet sound of carolers at your door on Christmas Eve…

But what if I told you this festive season - this perfect family holiday - had dark origins?

Sit back, grab a cup of hot cocoa (extra marshmallows, please), and join me as we unwrap the "dark origins" of Christmas.

Spoiler alert: it's not all candy canes and mistletoe kisses.

Found on https://www.history.com/topics/ancient-rome/saturnalia

It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Paganism

Before Christmas was, well, ... Christmas, it went by another name: Saturnalia.

As the winter solstice approached, this ancient Roman festival celebrated the god of agriculture, Saturn, and took place from December 17th to the 25th. (Today, the Winter Solstice occurs on December 21st).

Sounds familiar, huh? And guess what?

This was no carol-filled, family-fun time. To put it lightly, it was quite a debaucherous affair. Let's just say that the Romans definitely *knew how to party* – often to excess.

During Saturnalia, the norms of society were quite literally flipped upside down.

Slaves served as masters, feasts, and parties symbolized excess, and homes were adorned with wreaths and garlands – a symbol of pagan fertility gods.

Even the exchanging gifts Christmas tradition we know and love today comes, in part, from this raucous holiday.

The Romans brought Saturnalia to Medieval England in 43BC when they invaded England and British life was taken over by Roman life and its customs.

Feel your chestnuts roasting yet? Don't worry, there's more.

Found on https://mythopedia.com/topics/odin

Santa, Baby, or Should We Say… Odin?

Digging even deeper into the dark origins of Christmas history, we find ourselves in the Nordic world.

Have you ever stopped to wonder where the flying reindeer came from in our modern Santa Claus myth?

Well, look no further than the Norse Pagan god himself, Odin.

Odin, the all-seeing and all-knowing deity, was believed to have completed a hunting trip through the sky during the winter solstice, accompanied by his eight-legged horse (yes, eight legs) Sleipnir.

Sleipnir, in Norse mythology, is no ordinary horse. This remarkable creature, born of the mischievous god Loki, is renowned for its eight powerful and agile legs. These additional limbs, far from being a hindrance, allow Sleipnir to traverse land, sea, and air with ease, making him the fastest and most versatile mount in all the nine realms.

Photo Credit: Sleipnir by ConnyChiwa on DeviantArt

In traditional depictions, Sleipnir is often shown galloping through the sky, embodying the swiftness and strength that made him the preferred steed of Odin. This uniquely multi-legged horse has left hoof prints across many of our modern Christmas traditions, from Santa's magical midnight journey to the belief in flying reindeer.

Not only did villagers leave food out for this mighty god (similar to our beloved cookies and milk), but they also believed the ghosts of dead ancestors would visit during this time.

So, think of your family visits celebrating Christmas but with a little more…spirit?

The Metamorphosis: From Saturnalia to Christmas

The transformation of Saturnalia into Christmas is a fascinating journey that intertwines religion, culture, and politics.

When Rome officially embraced Christianity as the state religion in the 4th century AD, the church leaders faced a significant challenge. How could they incorporate the deeply entrenched pagan rituals into the new faith?

One of these was the widely celebrated festival of Saturnalia.

Rather than attempting to abolish these popular old traditions, the early Christian leaders decided to "Christianize" them.

December 25th was strategically chosen as the date to celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ, conveniently coinciding with the end of Saturnalia.

By the Middle Ages, this deft move allowed the Church to overshadow the pagan festival with a Christian celebration, thereby easing the transition for Rome's populace from paganism to Christianity.

Saturnalia's traditions, such as gift-giving, feasting, and decorating homes, were incorporated into the new celebration but given new, Christian interpretations.

So, while we still see echoes of Saturnalia in our modern Christmas customs, the original pagan meanings have been largely lost to time.

It is a testament to the adaptability of cultural practices and their ability to transform and survive across centuries.

Found on https://popehistory.com/popes/pope-st-julius-i/

Pope Julius I and the December 25th Decision

In the grand narrative of Christmas history, one figure stands out with a significant contribution - Pope Julius I.

Despite the many influences and adaptations over the centuries, the decision to celebrate Jesus Christ's birth on December 25th is attributed mainly to Pope Julius I.

In the fourth century CE, he officially declared this date as the celebration of Jesus's birth.

This clever choice was no random selection.

As already mentioned, this date coincided with the end of Saturnalia and the birthday of the unconquerable sun, thereby facilitating the transformation of a popular pagan festival into a Christian holiday.

The Pope's decision was a strategic move to ensure the smooth transition of the populace from pagan traditions to Christian celebrations.

His decision proved remarkably successful and enduring.

Even to this day, most of the world's Christian population celebrates Christmas on December 25th. Thus, the Pope's pivotal decision has left an indelible mark on the way we celebrate Christmas, illustrating the power of a single decision to shape centuries of cultural tradition.

PHOTO: theatlantic.com Found on https://historythings.com/krampusnacht-what-is-it-and-how-did-it-start/

Krampusnacht and the Feast of Saint Nicholas: A Tale of Two Holidays

Moving our journey further into the heart of December, two significant dates stand out:

  • December 5th, celebrated as Krampusnacht (Krampus Night), and
  • December 6th, known as the Feast of St. Nick.

These back-to-back celebrations, popular in many European countries, provide a striking contrast and a deeply rooted historical narrative.

Krampusnacht is a holiday honoring Krampus, a horned, anthropomorphic figure in Central and Eastern Alpine folklore. According to legend, Krampus punishes naughty children who have misbehaved, contrasting with Saint Nick, who rewards well-behaved ones with gifts.

  • On the eve of December 5th, individuals often dress as Krampus frightening children with clattering chains and bells.
  • The very next day, December 6th, is the Feast of Saint Nick, a day of joy and celebration.

St. Nicholas, known as the patron saint of children, is remembered for his kindness and generosity. On this day, good children wake up to presents left in their shoes, a reward for good behavior throughout the year.

These unique traditions highlight the duality of the holiday season, a blend of fear and joy, punishment, and reward. The dates also provide a fascinating look into how different cultures approach the concept of disciplining and rewarding children, as well as the broader theme of good versus evil.

https://lowellauditorium.com/calendar/2023/12/16/a-charlie-brown-christmas

The Evolution of Christmas: Embracing Light Over Darkness

As we've journeyed through the captivating history of Christmas, one theme stands out - an evolution from the shadows of fear towards the light of joy.

Today, the dark origins of yesteryear's Christmases like Krampusnacht have been largely overshadowed by more heartwarming Christmas traditions, with celebrations like "A Charlie Brown Christmas" and the Peanuts gang taking the spotlight, for example.

"A Charlie Brown Christmas," is a classic holiday tale, that embodies the true spirit of Christmas as we understand it today.

It underscores the importance of kinship, love, and the simple joys of life, as opposed to materialism.

This shift in focus from fear and punishment towards love, kindness, and generosity reflects the changes in societal values over time.

Christmas, as we know it today, serves as a beacon of hope and a time of reflection.

More than just a religious celebration, it has morphed into a global observance that transcends cultural and religious boundaries.

The meaning of Christmas today, irrespective of one's religious beliefs, is largely centered around peace, goodwill, and gratitude. It’s a time of year when people come together to celebrate love, friendship, and unity.

In essence, the evolution of Christmas represents humanity's inherent desire for love and peace over fear and discord.

Perhaps, that's the most important takeaway from our journey through Christmas history - the power of the human spirit to constantly seek light, even in the midst of darkness.

Good King Wenceslas: The Personification of Christmas Spirit

Good King Wenceslas is a central figure in a popular Christmas carol that has its roots in the 13th century.

Wenceslas was a real person. He was actually Duke Wenceslas of Bohemia, later canonized and known as Saint Wenceslas. Born around 907 AD, Wenceslas was known for his piety and kindness towards his subjects, particularly the poor and the underprivileged.

In the carol, he is depicted braving a harsh winter to provide alms to a poor peasant on the Feast of Stephen, which falls on December 26th.

This story encapsulates the spirit of generosity and goodwill associated with the Christmas season. His life and the subsequent legend that grew around him have made Wenceslas a symbol of benevolent leadership, and he is often remembered as an ideal monarch who cared deeply for his people.

https://www.biography.com/authors-writers/washington-irving

Washington Irving and the Transformation of Sinterklaas

As we delve further into the journey of Christmas history, we come across an influential figure, Washington Irving, an American writer known for his contributions to folklore and historical tales.

Irving played a significant role in the evolution of St. Nicholas, or 'Sinterklaas' from Dutch tradition, into the Christmas Traditions Santa we know today.

In his book "Knickerbocker's History of New York," published in 1809, Irving introduced a jovial, rotund, pipe-smoking St. Nicholas who flew over rooftops in a flying wagon, delivering gifts to children.

He blended Dutch folklore with his imagination, crafting a charming, approachable figure that veered away from the stern, bishop-like representation of Saint Nicholas in Dutch culture.

Irving's rendition of Sinterklaas was a hit, and it paved the way for the transformation of St. Nick into a symbol of cheer and generosity, embodied in the figure of Santa Claus.

It was this image that was later popularized and embellished in poems, songs, and visual arts, culminating in the Santa we all recognize today.

As such, Washington Irving's imaginative storytelling has left a lasting impact on Christmas traditions, underlining how the evolution of cultural practices can be influenced by art and literature.

Dickens and the Christmas Spirits

Charles Dickens' "A Christmas Carol" is perhaps one of the most iconic tales associated with the holidays, intertwining the yuletide cheer with elements of the supernatural.

In this timeless classic, Ebenezer Scrooge, a miserly old man, is visited by the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Yet to Come, on Christmas Eve. These spectral apparitions, each representing a facet of the spirit of Christmas, guide Scrooge on a journey of self-reflection and redemption.

  • The Ghost of Christmas Past, with its radiant glow, takes Scrooge back to his own past Christmases, reminding him of his lost innocence, unfulfilled dreams, and missed opportunities.
  • The Ghost of Christmas Present, a jolly giant adorned with a cornucopia of festive delicacies, shows Scrooge the current Christmas celebrations of others, revealing to him the joy, goodwill, and warmth that he is missing.
  • And the eerie Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come presents a grim future, a Christmas devoid of love and friendship, pushing Scrooge to mend his ways.

In this tale, Dickens uses the supernatural to explore the deeper meaning of Christmas. He highlights the transformative power of empathy, generosity, and the spirit of Christmas.

"A Christmas Carol", thus, not only adds a touch of the paranormal to Christmas literature but also serves as a timeless reminder of the true essence of the holidays - a message of love, kindness, and redemption.

Modern-Day Christmas Traditions: Beyond the Mistletoe and Gifts

As we delve further into the modern-day Christmas traditions, several noteworthy elements come to the forefront.

These include placing Christmas decorations around the house, decorating the Christmas tree, and the ubiquitous presence of Santa Claus.

The tradition of decorating the Christmas tree, with its origins in Germany, has become an integral part of Christmas traditions worldwide. This tradition involves embellishing an evergreen tree, typically a fir, spruce, or pine, with lights, ornaments, tinsel, and a star or an angel at the top, symbolizing the Star of Bethlehem.

The evergreen nature of these trees is a symbol of eternal life, which is a theme repeatedly emphasized in Christian teachings.

Another enduring tradition is the burning of the Yule log, a custom that predates Christianity and has its roots in the winter solstice celebrations. As part of this tradition, a large log is burned in the hearth to symbolize the return of the sun and the days becoming longer.

Today, in homes without a fireplace, the Yule log has transformed into a popular Christmas dessert, often a cake roll designed to resemble a log.

Lastly, the charming figure of Santa Claus, with his red suit and jolly demeanor, has come to personify the spirit of Christmas.

Derived from the Dutch interpretation of St. Nick, Santa Claus brings gifts to children globally on Christmas Eve. This tradition not only adds excitement to the festivities but also encourages the values of giving and spreading joy.

These traditions, along with many others, add to the rich tapestry of Christmas Day, each carrying a piece of history and a message of hope, peace, and joy.

So, as we're decorating trees, enjoying our Yule logs, watching "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer" reruns, and awaiting Santa's presents, we are participating in centuries-old customs, deeply rooted in our collective human experience.

Guilt-Free Christmas: A Reality or a Wish Upon a Star?

Now that we've taken a stroll down this lane filled with dark origins, let's ponder the question: Can we truly celebrate Christmas in all its twinkly glory without feeling the guilt of its murky past?

That, my dear readers, is ultimately up to you.

It's essential to remember that while the roots might be tangled in the twisted tinsel, the Christmas tradition today is about coming together. It's about a unity we all need and seek for, regardless of its history.

So, next time you're sipping your eggnog, battling with wrapping paper, and trimming the tree, embrace Christmas and its dark side, share a chuckle or two, and remember that our Christmas traditions have come a long way, and in doing so, become a part of the grand, ongoing narrative of Christmas Day.

After all, without a rich past, where would the future be?


Why Do People Hang Ornaments on Trees?
The history of Christmas ornaments and why we hang them on trees.


Share this post